Repair Or Replace Roof? 7+ Factors To Help You Decide

Should You Repair Or Replace Your Roof?

author profile picture

Posted By:Shingle & Metal Team

Repair or replace a roof? That is the question many homeowners ask themselves.

As a homeowner, one of your most important responsibilities is maintaining your roof’s integrity. It’s no secret that roofs can experience wear and tear over time, leaving you with an important question: should you repair or replace roof? The answer depends on various factors such as age, damage, materials used, and more.

For expert advice, always contact a professional roofing contractor first. 

Signs Your Roof Needs Attention

Here are some signs that a professional roofing contractor needs to look at your roof.

roofer repairing a small portion of a roof

Damaged Or Missing Shingles

Damaged or missing shingles play a significant role in assessing the health of your roof, as they serve as key indicators that may need attention.

It is important to routinely inspect your roof for signs of damage, such as cracked, buckling, warped, or curled shingles. Neglecting these warning signs could lead to more extensive problems down the line.

Water Leaks Or Stains

Water leaks or stains in your home should never be ignored, as they are clear indicators of a damaged roof that requires immediate attention. These issues can manifest themselves in various ways.

Identifying and addressing these signs of water intrusion is crucial for maintaining the integrity of your home’s roofing system. Enlisting the help of a professional roofing contractor will ensure that any necessary roof repairs are made promptly using high-quality materials designed for long-lasting performance against future weather damage.

Sagging Or Uneven Roof

A sagging roof leak indicates that your roofing system requires immediate attention. Ignoring this warning sign could lead to further damage to your home.

It’s important to regularly inspect your roof for patches or gaps between shingles, missing nail heads, or poorly nailed shingles – all of which can signify an underlying issue with sagging or unevenness in a few shingles.

Additionally, if you notice bald spots on your shingles where granules have worn away completely, this could also indicate serious issues which warrant repair or replacement of new shingles for the entire roofing system.

Age Of The Roof

The roof’s age is crucial in determining whether to repair or replace it. For example, asphalt shingle roofs typically have a lifespan of 20 to 25 years after complete roof replacement, while other types may last up to 30 years with proper maintenance.

Bear in mind that if your current roof is over 20 years old, you should consider replacing it rather than repairing it as most roofs last between 20-25 years at maximum.

Factors To Consider When Choosing To Repair Or Replace Roof

Consider the severity of the damage, costs, and long-term benefits when deciding between repairing or replacing your roof.

Severity Of Damage

The severity of damage is a crucial factor to consider when deciding whether to repair or replace your roof. However, minor issues with the roof deck, such as small leaks or missing shingles, can often be solved with simple repairs.

workers stripping off an old roof

Ignoring severe roof damage can lead to costly consequences such as structural failure or collapse. It’s essential to seek professional assistance in assessing the severity of any roofing issues and determining the best course of action for addressing them promptly.


The cost of repairing or replacing a roof depends on several critical factors, including the extent and type of roofing material, damage, roofing materials, building codes and regulations, and urgency.

For instance, if your entire roof replacement part is only a few years old but has suffered significant damage due to extreme weather conditions like hailstorms or wind damage that are beyond repair.

On the other hand, replacing an old and damaged roof with a new one can significantly increase energy efficiency while adding curb appeal to your home when the roof inspection is done correctly.

Long-Term Benefits

By replacing an aging or damaged roof, homeowners can extend the lifespan of the existing roof toping system and protect their homes from water damage and other environmental elements.

In addition to functional benefits, a new roof adds curb appeal and can increase the value of your home. It is not uncommon for homeowners who invest in a new roof to see a return on investment in the form of increased home value when selling their house.

full roof replacement

Making The Right Decision

To determine whether to repair or replace your roof, you should consider factors such as the severity of the damage, costs, and long-term benefits of roof repair.

Comparing Repair Vs. Replacement

When deciding whether to repair or replace your roof, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option. If the damage is minor, a repair may be sufficient. However, if the issues are widespread or significant, replacing the entire roof may be necessary.

One of the most significant advantages of replacing your roof is its increased lifespan. Investing in a new roof can give you peace of mind knowing that your home is protected from future weather-related damage for years to come.

Importance Of Energy Efficiency

An often overlooked factor in deciding whether to repair or replace your roof is the importance of energy efficiency. Energy-efficient roofing materials and designs can significantly reduce peak cooling demand, saving you money on energy bills.

It’s important to note that not all roofs are created equal when it comes to energy efficiency. Factors such as color, insulation, and age can affect how much heat is absorbed or reflected by your roof.

Increased Home Value

old house with a orange door before roof repair

Installing a new roof can significantly increase the resale value of your home. According to a recent study, replacing an old roof with a new one can boost the appraisal value by over $17,000.

This is because a new roof improves your home’s curb appeal and makes it more attractive to prospective buyers. Aesthetically pleasing homes sell for higher prices than those needing major repairs or renovations.

Get In Touch With The Professionals

In conclusion, deciding whether to repair or replace your roof ultimately depends on the severity of damage and long-term benefits. While repairs may be a quick fix for minor issues, a complete roof replacement may be necessary for more extensive damage or an old roof nearing the end of its lifespan.

Consider affordability, energy efficiency, and increased home value when deciding on a full roof replacement. Remember, regular maintenance can help extend the life of your roof and save you money in the long run. Contact Shingle & Metal Roofs today! 

Your Happiness Is Our Satisfaction